How to Switch Websites Without Losing Your Google Rankings
A new site loses rankings when old page addresses stop working. How to list them, redirect each to its closest new page and check Search Console after launch.
A lot of owners know their website is costing them work and still put off a new one. The worry is always the same: the old site ranks for something, the phone rings from it now and then, and a new site might make that stop. It is a fair worry. A new site loses rankings when the addresses Google already knows stop working.
This article walks through how to move to a new site and keep what the old one earned, using a real move we made in October 2026 for Xtreme Scapes, a family owned outdoor living contractor in Melbourne that builds screen enclosures, pool cages, pavers and fences.
Why a new site loses rankings
Google does not rank your business as a whole. It ranks pages, and each page lives at an address, like yoursite.com/pavers. When a new site moves your paver page to a new address and nothing points the old one at it, a homeowner who clicks the old result gets a “page not found” error. Google sees the same error and, over time, drops the page.
Xtreme Scapes was on its third website. Google still listed pages from both earlier sites: an older WordPress site and the site that replaced it. Plenty of those addresses returned “page not found” before we started. One old screen room page was still among the business’s best results in search, on a site that was about to disappear.
Google’s own advice for a move is direct: “It’s important to map your old site’s URLs to the URLs for the new site.” It also warns: “Expect temporary fluctuation in site ranking during the move.”
Source: Google Search Central, “Site moves with URL changes”. Checked November 14, 2026.
Step 1: list every address Google knows
Before anything changes, make a list of every page on the old site that Google has seen. The best places to look:
- Search Console’s Page indexing report. Its “Not found (404)” list shows addresses Google tried that already fail. Google describes it as a page that “returned a 404 error when requested.” Pages listed as crawled but not indexed belong on the list too.
- The old site’s sitemap. Save a copy before the old site goes away.
- Every older site you ever had. Ask whoever built them, or search Google for your business name. Old pages from a site two builders ago can still show up.
Source: Search Console Help, “Page indexing report”. Checked November 14, 2026.
For Xtreme Scapes this list ran to more than 250 addresses: service pages, town pages, old blog posts, contact and about pages under old names, and odd copies of pages that only existed because of how the old sites were built.
Step 2: send each old page to its closest new page
Go down the list and pick, for each old address, the one new page that covers the same thing. An old page about landscape installation in Merritt Island now points to the new Merritt Island page. Every old screen room page now points to the new screen enclosures and pool cages page, which is where that work lives now.
The shortcut people take is sending everything to the home page. Google says not to: “Don’t redirect many old URLs to one irrelevant single URL destination, such as the home page of the new site.” It may treat those as errors anyway.
The question for each old page: if a homeowner clicked this in Google, which new page answers what they were looking for?
Moving to a new site? We map every old page before launch, so the addresses Google knows keep working.
Book more jobs →Step 3: use permanent redirects, one hop each
A redirect is the instruction that sends a visitor, and Google, from the old address to the new one. Google recommends “a permanent server-side redirect whenever possible” and says the 301 and 308 codes “mean that a page has permanently moved to a new location.” A permanent redirect also tells Google to show the new page in results instead of the old one.
Point each old address straight at its final page. If an old page goes to a second old page that then goes to the new one, that is a chain. Google advises “redirecting to the final destination directly.”
Sources: Google Search Central, “Redirects and Google Search”; Google Search Central, “Site moves with URL changes”. Checked November 14, 2026.
Xtreme’s redirect file ended up with more than 500 rules, one for each old address and each variation of it. Each rule is one line: this old address goes to that new page.
Step 4: let junk pages stay gone
Not every old address deserves a new home. Website themes leave behind demo pages, sample shop pages and blank templates that were never about your business. Google found plenty of those on Xtreme’s old sites. We left them returning “page not found” on purpose, so Google drops them instead of tying them to a real page.
Step 5: fix everything else that points at the old site
Redirects catch visitors who arrive at old addresses. You still want the places you control to point at the new ones directly:
- Your Google Business Profile. Check the website link, and any links in your services or posts.
- Directory listings. Yelp, Angi, Facebook and the rest often still show an old page address, phone number or mailing address.
- Free sites from your job software or an old builder. Xtreme had one with an old phone number on it. Take it down or update it.
- Links inside the new site. Google says to change internal links “from the old URLs to the new URLs” and to update your sitemap.
Step 6: keep the redirects and watch for errors
Leave the redirects in place. Google says to keep them “for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year.” For the first few weeks, open Search Console and check whether “Not found” errors are climbing. Google’s advice is to “check regularly for any unexpected crawl errors.” Each new error is an old address you missed. Add it to the list.
If someone is building you a new site, ask them three things before launch day: where is the list of old addresses, where does each one go, and who checks Search Console after launch.
Is your old site still sending you calls?
We build your new site and map every old page before launch, so the addresses Google knows keep working.
Book more jobs →Related
Start here
For the full picture, read our main article: Home Services Website Design That Books Jobs.